Friday, December 23, 2011
Yazdanfar surrenders license
Saturday, July 24, 2010
Yazdanfar disciplinary hearing before the CPSO
On July 13, 2009 Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar's disciplinary hearing began before the CPSO in Toronto. It is now July 23, 2010 and the hearing has been going on for over one year.
Christie Blatchford - Globe and Mail attacks the CPSO and Yazdanfar
- Disciplinary hearing shows the ugly side of cosmetic surgery - July 23, 2010
- Defence suggests doctor victim of witch hunt in liposuction death - July 22, 2010
- Prosecution portrays stunning failures in liposuction death - July 21, 2010
- Complaint against lipsuction doctor was a perceptive warning - July 14, 2010
Robert Cribb - Toronto Star - July 24, 2010
- Lipo death puts cosmetic surgery under microscope
Medical watchdog to make crucial judgment on professional standards
For the latest news and commentary please use the following searches:
I'm not listing the Toronto SUN's web site because this organization helped to promote Dr. Yazdanfar's clinic over the years.
Wednesday, July 14, 2010
Liposuction deaths - videos
- Spa Mistreatment - ABC Nightline - March 9, 2010
- Questions arise after a death during a liposuction. Florida doctor, Brito Marin, finally loses his license after death of mother at a spa that reads tanning and nails over the door. What the hell is a medical doctor doing in a place like this in the first place?
Sunday, June 7, 2009
Yazdanfar's lawyers appeal quashed to remove license restrictions
Friday, March 27, 2009
HPARB rejects complaint
HPARB sat on it until March 23, 2009 to render a decision. If you want to see a full copy of their decision contact us directly.
"..the Board confirms the decision of the Complaints Committee to take no further action in relation to the complaint, but recommends that the College consider whether a licensed family physician whose practice is cosmetic medicine be required to use, when set forth credentials, clear language to convey that he or she is a licensed as a family physician."
This basically lets Yazdanfar off the hook. She is still basically practicing as she was before, with only minor changes to her own web site.
In April 2007 the CPSO initiated a new policy called the Cosmetic Procedures Initiative: Steps to Improve Patient Safety - Implementation of four-point plan to ensure public safety.
You can follow the links to various efforts that they have made. Whether or not anybody is going to be taken to task for not complying is yet to be seen.
One of these is from the Council Updates in April 2008.
"Council approved regulation amendments that will require physicians to be clear and accurate about their credentials and training in their advertising and other communications with patients."
Did Yazdanfar do anything to adhere to these updates?
She and her husband continue to operate their TCC and issue press releases as if nothing has happened. She still says this about herself:
"Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar is a premier Toronto doctor based in North York, Ontario, Canada. Leading a dedicated and professional staff at Toronto Cosmetic Clinic, she focuses on surgical and non-surgical cosmetic surgery procedures, having performed cosmetic procedures since the year 2000. She frequently performs breast augmentation and liposuction, as well as several other aesthetic procedures."
Of course there is no mention of Krista Stryland or the lawsuit.
If you are upset about this, talk to your MPP to the Ontario legislature. HPARB has basically rubber-stamped whatever the CPSO did. The public has no redress.
Friday, February 20, 2009
RipOff Report on Dr. Yazdanfar
The post below was posted by a former patient of Yazdafar on Ripoff Report.com. Liposuction Watch is not responsible for the content of the post, and the spelling mistakes have been left as they were posted.
Dr. Yazdanfar may be successful at getting patients, due to the lies she tells, and the trust that people put in her without knowing she is NOT really a surgeon at all; but she has trouble keeping them, because alot of them end up with problems that need to be fixed by a certified Plastic Sugeon.
I was an unfortunate patient of Dr. Yazdanfar for a breast Augmentation...unfortunitly for me I developed a capsular contracture (the most common of all complications) so Dr. Yazdanfar removed my scar tissue, only for the same thing to happen almost instantly again. After which I was advised to leave the capsule in place and put a smaller implant inside to regain the softness. I had never heard of this, so when I got home I started researching to find that that is NOT a treatment option!!!!
Why would she recommed something to me that was unheard of in the cosmetic Surgery community?? Next I discovered that she was NOt a surgeon...just a family doctor, and that it is very dangerous for you not to have an I.v. in the recovery room, as it is needed for emergencies. (thank god I never had an complication in recovery after my surgery)
A certified Plastic Surgeon saw me, and had to remove the implants and the scar tissue (with next to no pain or bruising)...and I have to wait 4-6 months to heal from what she did, before he can do a recontruction. So after two painful surgeries with her, I can tell you first hand it is not worth the risk...she needs to be stoped. She calls herself a surgeon...she's NOT
Must end
guelph, Ontario
Canada
Monday, July 28, 2008
Lipo patient's wounds 'excessive'
- Toronto Star July 23, 2008
Robert Cribb
Woman who died after surgery allegedly had 23 incisions, court documents show
A Toronto mother who died after liposuction surgery last year allegedly had 23 incisions made in six different body parts in one session – an "excessive" amount that could have contributed to her death, according to allegations in court documents.
The provincial coroner also raised red flags about the number of incisions and body parts, the documents show. "The patient had liposuction on both legs, buttocks, back, abdomen and chest wall. This seemed to be excessive," says a memo written by college investigator Sandra Keough quoting Dr. James Edwards at the Office of the Chief Coroner. "There was a lot of locations for fat removal and this may play into the cause of death."
Tuesday, January 29, 2008
The search for integrity in the cosmetic surgery market
Following Stryland’s death, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario canvassed the more than 2400 members to determine the extent to which doctors may have expanded their practices to include cosmetic and aesthetic procedures without having obtained appropriate training. It is believed several hundred doctors, mostly family physicians, have been advertising themselves as “cosmetic surgeons,” but have not been telling patients they are not formally qualified to perform surgery.
Thursday, December 20, 2007
A present that could leave you scarred
By LEAH HARDY -
11th December 2007
When Denise Zaccaria's children grew up and left home, she felt it was time "to do something for myself".
So, at the age of 42, she decided on breast implants. "I was still quite young, and wanted to have a nice figure again. I thought of it as a treat, like a facial or pedicure. It didn't occur to me that it could go wrong."
The Nottinghamshire office manager tried to be responsible in choosing a surgeon, asking friends for recommendations. She finally found what she thought was a reputable clinic, and paid a visit.
"As soon as I walked in, they tried to book me in for surgery. Then they kept calling me. I felt pressured and didn't trust them," she says.
Then a friend suggested a clinic she'd heard about in Manchester. "I made an appointment and met a surgeon, who was from abroad."I had one brief meeting and he was keen for me to go ahead quickly. He seemed nice and I decided to trust him. I was never warned about complications, just that my implants would probably last 15 years."
However, a few years after the operation, Denise felt a hard ridge under her left breast.
"I thought I had breast cancer and was petrified. Soon, both breasts were hard and tender. I could no longer sleep on my front and my breasts started to look unnatural."
Denise was suffering from encapsulation - where scar tissue adheres to the implant. It's a complication in up to one in ten breast operations. But no one had warned Denise.
Her experience is not unusual. Experts warn that many women are having cosmetic surgery with no idea of the risks.
Inspired by celebrities and TV makeover shows, more of us are turning to surgery to improve our looks.
The number of procedures has risen from 202,000 to 700,000 in just four years. And with Christmas around the corner, clinics are experiencing a boom.
"We've seen a huge demand for vouchers, and we expect to see even more in the run-up to Christmas," says a spokeswoman for Transform Cosmetic Surgery Group, Britain's largest chain.
According to the British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (Baaps), many people choose treatments such as Botox injections at this time of the year as a treat.
To cash in on this booming market, some other clinics are breaking the law.
A recent report from consumer watchdog Which? exposed an array of hardsell tactics, including offering patients discounts to book immediately (against the industry's code of conduct), advertising Botox (illegal) and using "before and after" photographs without making it clear the results are not achievable for everyone.
Which? says all this breaches the letter and spirit of codes of conduct of the regulatory bodies that govern the industry's behaviour.
None of this comes as a surprise to leading cosmetic surgeon Dai Davies. He is a former research fellow and examiner for trainee surgeons for the Royal College of Surgeons, as well as a consultant in plastic and reconstructive surgery at three London NHS hospitals.
He has long been concerned by the lack of industry regulation.
"It's been going on for years," he says. "The Government had the opportunity to do something about these abuses, but chose not to by opting for self-regulation.
"Cosmetic surgery is big business, so it's not surprising to get the 'pile 'em high, sell 'em cheap' mentality.
"Many women spend more time picking a bathroom suite than choosing their surgeon. Yet surgery is a serious matter."
Davies says patients don't realise the true complication rate of their chosen procedures, or may be at risk from "cut-and-run" foreign surgeons who fly to Britain to perform conveyor belt operations, then disappear home.
"I would urge women to be careful of foreign surgeons who fly in from abroad. They may meet the patient only on the day of the surgery.
"Also, British training is longer than in Europe. You can get on the specialist register in Greece after three years. Here, it is six."
Consultant plastic surgeon Norman Waterhouse, a former president of Baaps, agrees.
"The principles of best practice would seem compromised as the surgeon would operate, then leave the next day, which doesn't allow for continuity of care," he says.
Face-lifts, tummy tucks and liposuction also have high complication rates, including nerve damage, chronic pain and even death.
Former Scotland football captain Colin Hendry's wife, Denise, nearly died in a bungled liposuction operation five years ago, when her bowel was pierced six times.
Last October, she was rushed into hospital suffering from a recurrence of the blood infection that put her in a coma for five weeks and left her badly scarred.
In a separate case, surgeon Brian Gwynn, 54, is facing an inquiry by the General Medical Council after being accused of leaving at least six patients disfigured and in pain after breast operations.
The Medical Defence Union, the biggest provider of medical indemnity to doctors, has paid out just under £8.5 million in compensation and legal costs over the past ten years to patients harmed by cosmetic surgery.
"Some patients have unrealistic expectations of what can be achieved by cosmetic procedures, and what risks are involved," says Dr Christine Tomkins, deputy chief executive of the MDU.
Dai Davies urges caution. "Most cosmetic surgery is safe, because it is performed on healthy people, but bad cosmetic surgery is with you for life."
When Denise Zaccaria was told by her GP that she was suffering from a complication of her surgery, she chose not to return to the clinic where she'd had the operation.
"Instead, I chose a fully qualified British-based surgeon at a Reform clinic. This time there was no hard sell. My surgeon was very honest.
"He warned me that encapsulation could happen again, and that the operation would involve the removal of scar tissue, making it more complex.
"He wanted two consultations with me before I went ahead and, because of my fear of cancer, insisted on a mammogram and ultrasound scan between the two.
"The results of my second surgery are great, though it hurt more afterwards, probably because of the scar tissue removal."
Here, Dai Davies explains the health risks of the most popular forms of surgery:
• BREAST AUGMENTATION: Small risk of internal bleeding and infection. Much higher risk of encapsulation, where scar tissue builds up around the implant, causing pain and a strange look to the breast.
• LIPOSUCTION: The third most popular cosmetic surgery procedure, with demand up 90 per cent since 2005. Complications, while rare, can be serious. Internal organs can be punctured, leading to blood poisoning, and clots that go to the lung. Patients can go into shock, develop infection or suffer injury to internal organs. They can also be left with dents, lumps and sagging skin.
• TUMMY TUCK: There are many complications involved, and some surgeons think of it as a two-stage procedure. The first to do the operation and the second for "touch-ups", such as removing excess skin. There can also be problems with wound healing, scarring and infection.
• FACE-LIFT: Immediate risks include bleeding, scarring, asymmetry and lumpiness. Nerve damage is common. All patients will have temporary numbness, but for one in 1,000 cases it is permanent. One in 100 can be left with an asymmetric smile.
• RHINOPLASTY (NOSE JOB): While complications are unusual, this has a high dissatisfaction rate. Some patients can't breathe through their new nose or are unhappy that too much was taken away.
• EYELID SURGERY: Sometimes too much skin is removed from the lower eyelid, resulting in "scleral show" where the lid is pulled down too much so you can see the white under the eye.
Estate of dead Tennessee Dr. Bruce Pancake sued for alleged negligence and fraud
December 11, 2007
Ten patients of the late Dr. Bruce Pancake are suing his estate in Circuit Court, alleging professional negligence, misrepresentation and fraud.
The suit that asks unspecified damages is brought against Dr. Pancake's widow, Deborah Pancake.
The suit says Dr. Pancake committed suicide at his office in East Brainerd on Sept. 17.
It says Dr. Pancake initially held himself out as an otolaryngologist treating problems affecting the ear, nose and throat. It says, after patient complaints involving ENT procedures, Dr. Pancake "changed specialties and held himself out as a plastic surgeon."
The suit says Dr. Pancake did not complete an internship, residency or fellowship in plastic surgery, but attended a two-day seminar in Kalgenfurt, Austria, in 2004 to learn cosmetic breast surgery.
The complaint says Dr. Pancake�s operating facilities were not licensed or accredited. It says he "did not advise his patients that his surgical privileges at Hamilton County, Tennessee, hospitals had been withdrawn, restricted, suspended, limited, or denied."
It says Dr. Pancake "intentionally and recklessly misrepresented the benefits of using only local anesthesia for all of his procedures when the true reason he choose only local anesthesia for the procedures was due to his lack of skill, training and experience and the limitations placed upon him by his inability to gain access to area hospitals."
The complaint says Dr. Pancake "generally failed to practice and use proper sterile technique during his surgical procedures and did not use proper sterile technique with the Plaintiffs. He generally failed to properly scrub, failed to maintain a sterile surgical suite or field, and exposed his patients to an unreasonable risk of infection. Dr. Pancake generally did not use masks or caps during surgery. He generally did not properly prepare his patients for surgery, and failed to use antiseptic agents on his patients to reduce the risk of infection. He allowed people to enter the surgical field without scrubbing or wearing sterile clothing. He often went from one operating room to another without changing scrubs or gloves. He often would enter the surgical field while wearing his work-out clothes and dripping with perspiration after exercising next door at the Athletic Club. Dr. Pancake used Maxipads to cover the Plaintiffs� surgical wounds."
The 44-page lawsuit alleges various medical problems experienced by the plaintiffs after undergoing surgery by Dr. Pancake.
The suit was filed by attorneys Eric Oliver and Andy Lewis.
They issued this statement on Wednesday:
"On Dec. 11, 2007, the law firm of Lewis & Oliver filed a complaint in the Circuit Court of Hamilton County, Tennessee on behalf of 10 former patients of Dr. Bruce Pancake. These patients underwent a variety of surgical procedures performed by Dr. Pancake at his Gunbarrel Road facility known as The Phoenix Center Spa Medicus.
"These patients suffered injuries and damages which we believe were the result of inappropriate actions by Dr. Pancake as specifically set forth in the complaint.
"We regret that the publicity arising out of this legal action may cause distress for Dr. Pancake�s family. However, the painful, serious injuries, including disfigurement, to these patients required this action to be filed.
"We hope that these cases can be resolved in such a way that the injured patients will be fairly compensated while, at the same time, minimizing any distress to Dr. Pancake�s family."
Wednesday, December 12, 2007
MD under fire from colleagues for hiring spy
Toronto Star
Tanya Talaga
Staff Reporters
Three of the largest professional organizations representing plastic surgeons in Canada are filing formal complaints against a Toronto physician who hired a private investigator to spy on a colleague whom she suspected was causing a drop in her business.
The Ontario Society of Plastic Surgery, the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgery and the Canadian Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery plan to ask Ontario's medical watchdog to investigate Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar's decision to send an undercover female investigator to consult with plastic surgeon Dr. Sean Rice and secretly record the conversation.
As the Star reported last week, Yazdanfar used the recording as the basis of a $300,000 lawsuit against Rice, alleging the plastic surgeon slandered her reputation.
"Nobody has ever seen anything like this," says Dr. Michael Weinberg, a Toronto-area plastic surgeon and member of the three organizations filing complaints with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario.
"We would like them to investigate the ethics of wiring an investigator to come in, ask questions, to pretend to be a patient and pose naked."
Weinberg says members of the three organizations decided to file the complaints Monday.
"The medical community is very upset by this," he said. "I can't imagine that asking a woman to expressly lie to a doctor and then to have their breast examined by a doctor and that person being sent by another doctor for the sole purpose of trapping them could be considered in any way ethical."
College officials would not comment.
"I can confirm we are investigating Dr. Yazdanfar, but I can't provide you with details of the investigation or how the matter came to our attention," said Kathryn Clarke, college spokesperson.
Yazdanfar has been at the centre of controversy since Krista Stryland, a 32-year-old real estate agent and mother, was pronounced dead in hospital Sept. 20 following a liposuction procedure at Yazdanfar's Toronto Cosmetic Clinic.
Yazdanfar, a family physician without hospital privileges or a surgical specialty, claims in her lawsuit that she hired the investigator to determine whether Rice was the cause of a dramatic drop in her business this past fall – the same time Stryland's death was the subject of major headlines.
Rice tried to revive Stryland when she was rushed to hospital.
Neither Yazdanfar nor Rice has commented on the allegations in the lawsuit. None of the allegations have been proven in court.
Michael Kestenberg, Yazdanfar's lawyer, said yesterday his client is unaware of any complaints filed against her. "Until such a time my client and I see the complaints, we are not in a position to comment."
Yazdanfar's lawyers have also sent a letter to two other plastic surgeons warning them to refrain from making disparaging comments about her to patients on the threat of legal action, the Star has learned.
Doctors say the case goes to the core of the physician-patient relationship.
"A physician has to be able to speak honestly to their patients," says Weinberg. "As a patient, wouldn't you want to go to your doctor and ask for an honest opinion even if it isn't to the benefit of a company, institution or another doctor?"
Dr. Brian Peterson, president of the Canadian Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, said his organization's letter of complaint will be filed with the college this week.
"It will be about professional conduct," he said. "It's not normal activity to take the steps she's taken."
Saturday, December 8, 2007
Doctor in lipo controversy hired spy to scout MDs
Tanya Talaga
Staff Reporters
The Toronto family doctor whose patient died after undergoing liposuction in September hired a private investigator to pose as a patient and spy on a competitor she alleges in a lawsuit is responsible for her drop in business.
Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar, a family physician without a surgical specialty or hospital privileges, performed the liposuction.
She has filed a $300,000 slander suit against plastic surgeon Dr. Sean Rice based on a secretly recorded conversation he had with a private investigator who visited him last month pretending to be interested in breast enlargement surgery and liposuction.
Rice was one of the physicians who tried unsuccessfully to revive Krista Stryland when she was brought into North York General Hospital on Sept. 20 after liposuction surgery at Yazdanfar's Toronto Cosmetic Clinic on Yonge St.
Stryland, a 32-year-old real estate agent and mother, died in hospital.
In a statement of claim filed in court by the Toronto Cosmetic Clinic and Yazdanfar, she says she suffered "a marked decline in profitability and unusual increase in the number of patient cancellations for scheduled cosmetic surgeries" this fall.
None of the allegations have been proven in court.
The drop in business prompted her to hire an investigative firm "to make inquiries within the cosmetic surgery industry and among competitors to determine if the business decline was related to or caused by competitors defaming (her)," the statement reads.
Yazdanfar did not respond to a request for an interview.
Her clinic's manager directed questions to lawyer Michael Kestenberg who would not offer comment on the allegations.
Rice also declined to comment and referred calls to his lawyer Brian Butler.
"Unquestionably there will be a statement of defence," Butler said. "Dr. Rice will defend himself."
Rice isn't the only physician to be targeted by Yazdanfar. At least one other doctor has received a letter from Yazdanfar's lawyers ordering him to "cease and desist" from making critical remarks on the threat of legal action, the Star has learned.
On Oct. 17, just a month after Stryland's death, investigator Francine Doyle attended a scheduled consultation for breast augmentation and liposuction with Rice at his Sheppard Ave. E. clinic, the statement of claim says.
Doyle, equipped with a hidden audio recording device, told Rice she had already had a consultation with Yazdanfar at the Cosmetic Clinic, the suit alleges.
Rice allegedly provided Doyle with different methods and types of breast implants and explained the differences between products offered by two companies. The suit alleges Rice told Doyle that one manufacturer won't sell to Yazdanfar and the other would only sell her saline implants.
Yazdanfar said in her statement of claim that's not true although one of the companies, Allergan Canada, confirmed to the Star last night it only sells breast implants to certified plastic surgeons.
The claim further alleges that when Doyle expressed hesitation to Rice regarding the safety of liposuction he made the following statements, "If anything were to happen to you here, we have everything here, a Royal College plastic surgeon, Royal College anesthesiologist, all RN certified nurses and everybody knows CPR ...
It continues: "You're not going to get anybody, who (is) more trained, than what you would get here in the office. Compared to (an) outside clinic, which doesn't have an RN, a Royal College certified anesthesiologist. Something happens to you there, they are like, and ok what do I (do) right ..."
The claim says the Toronto Cosmetic Clinic employs licensed anesthesiologists and "nurses registered with the college.
"Further, Dr. Yazdanfar at all times conducts the liposuction procedure in the presence of and with the assistance of a college certified anesthesiologist."
Yazdanfar, a graduate of the University of Ottawa who doesn't hold hospital privileges, said the words Rice spoke to Doyle were "slanderous" and "were calculated by him to disparage and injure the Cosmetic Clinic's business and Dr. Yazdanfar's professional reputation."
Rice is a plastic surgeon, certified by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons, and he has hospital privileges at North York General, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre and Women's College Hospital.
Following Stryland's late September death, Yazdanfar and her clinic were the subject of front-page headlines and broadcast news reports focusing on the lack of regulation around cosmetic surgery in Ontario.
In response to mounting pressure from the media and the public after her death, the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons proposed tighter regulations for the cosmetic surgery industry.
The measures include restrictions against use of the phrase "cosmetic surgeon" for those who hold no surgical speciality and proposed inspections of private clinics where cosmetic procedures are done.
Two weeks ago, college officials said they are investigating 16 doctors performing high-risk cosmetic procedures in private clinics that could be a danger to the public because of concerns about their qualifications and training. They would not identify the physicians by name.
Contact Yazdanfar's lawyer Michael R. Kestenberg- E-mail: mrk@ksllaw.com
- Phone: 416-597-0000 Ext. 111
- Mail: 65 Granby Street , Toronto , ON M5B 1H8
- E-mail: bbutler@lerners.ca
- Phone: 416-601-2353
- Fax 416.867.2427
- Mail: 130 Adelaide St. West, Suite 2400
P.O. Box 95, Toronto ON M5H 3P5
Sunday, November 25, 2007
Dubai Probes Woman’s Death After Plastic Surgery with Laser Liposuction device
DUBAI, 23 November 2007 — Health authorities in Dubai are investigating the death of an Emirati woman who recently went into coma after undergoing plastic surgery and subsequently died.
The woman had undergone laser liposuction costing 90,000 dirhams at a private clinic. The operation was later done in a private hospital, as the clinic did not have the facilities to undertake the operation.
The death from plastic surgery is the first in the UAE. Plastic surgery is growing in popularity in the UAE with many clinics heavily advertising their services in local newspapers and beauty magazines.
Dr. Eisa Kazem, from the Dubai Department of Health and Medical Services, said the woman sustained brain damage after surgery, which took several hours. She then went in a coma and was taken by her family to Tawam Hospital in Al-Ain City where she died a few days later.
Dr. Kazem said that the Dubai Department of Health and Medical Services is investigating the death and has suspended a plastic surgeon and anesthetist, who performed the operation and revoked their medical licenses.
A committee comprising a neurosurgeon, two plastic surgeons and an anesthetic specialist will investigate the case. If it is found that there was malpractice then legal action will be taken. Malpractice in the UAE is punishable with a fine, revoking of the medical license and criminal prosecution.
The Dubai Department of Health and Medical Services has received 89 cases of malpractice from patients in the past year. Complaints were received against four government hospitals, and 36 private hospitals and clinics. Out of those, 32 cases were found to be true. The Dubai Department of Health and Medical Services took the necessary action against the guilty party.
Wednesday, November 21, 2007
The beauty of anonymity
It has been too long in coming, but the agency that regulates medical practices in Ontario is finally moving toward a crackdown on ill-trained cosmetic surgeons who may pose a risk to patients.
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario has launched an investigation into 16 doctors who perform high-risk cosmetic procedures in private clinics. These physicians have not necessarily done anything wrong but there is concern over whether they have the qualifications and training necessary for full public confidence in their abilities. The doctors came under scrutiny after the college had physicians fill out a mandatory questionnaire about the nature of their cosmetic surgery practice and their qualifications. Another 20 doctors did not answer all necessary questions and have been told they risk losing their medical licence unless they respond to the survey.
None of the physicians in question has been identified by the college.
The 16 doctors who are of most concern are being evaluated by trained assessors and, in the absence of hard evidence of problems, the college insists they have a right to continue practising.
That's fair, but patients also have a right to be told that their doctor is under investigation, or that their physician failed to complete a mandatory questionnaire concerning professional qualifications.
Instead, the college has opted to leave Ontarians in the dark.
The current crackdown comes less than two months after Krista Stryland, a Toronto mother and real estate agent, died in the wake of liposuction from a self-dubbed "cosmetic surgeon" who was not a certified plastic surgeon. That tragedy happened after years of official inaction on this public safety issue.
Hopefully no one else will die as the college assesses doctors whose right to continue doing business trumps the public's right to know.
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
CPSO Statement on Cosmetic Surgery
November 19, 2007
Today, cosmetic surgery and non-surgical cosmetic procedures are more in demand than ever before. Whether you are considering actual surgery or any other type of cosmetic procedure, you should make sure that you have all the information you need to make a properly informed decision before proceeding.
To help you make an informed decision, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario has put together this information, which includes an explanation of the different kinds of doctors who provide services, the important issues you should be aware of when considering cosmetic surgery, and a list of questions to ask before making a decision about having cosmetic surgery. In keeping with the College’s mandate to ensure quality medical practice, the regulation of cosmetic surgery providers is being enhanced to make certain that the doctor you choose has the skills and knowledge to provide safe medical care. When changes are made, this fact sheet will be updated to reflect those changes.
Most of this fact sheet focuses on cosmetic surgery because of the higher risks involved in surgical procedures rather than non-surgical cosmetic procedures. You will also find some helpful questions to ask if you are considering a cosmetic procedure that does not involve surgery.
If you or someone you know is considering any cosmetic procedure be sure to make an informed decision by finding out everything you can about that procedure, the qualifications of the person doing the procedure and the facility where it is being done.
What is Cosmetic Surgery?
Cosmetic surgery involves incisions or significant alteration of the skin or underlying tissues and can involve many areas of the face and body. Common facial cosmetic procedures include facelift, brow lift, eyelid surgery, ear surgery, and rhinoplasty (nose) surgery. Less invasive cosmetic facial surgeries include facial liposuction, facial implants, micro fat grafting, and some laser resurfacing procedures. Common cosmetic surgical procedures done on the body include liposuction, abdominoplasty (tummy tuck), breast lift, breast enhancement (augmentation). There are many other procedures targeted to nearly every part of the body.
All surgery comes with possible risks of complications -- from anaesthesia, infection, and scarring, for example. Such complications can be minor or major and, in rare circumstances, even death can occur. Cosmetic surgery is no exception and the decision to consent to surgery is always an important one.
What kinds of doctors perform cosmetic surgery?
Presently, in Ontario, any medical doctor may perform surgical procedures, including cosmetic surgery. When you discuss cosmetic procedures with your doctor, make sure that he or she has the right qualifications and experience. Surgical procedures should only be done by doctors who have the appropriate training and experience.
Checking qualifications
Some doctors provide details of their qualifications by placing letters after their name, e.g., Dr. Jacob Smith, MD, FRCSC. Some display certificates in their clinics. But it can often be difficult to work out what the letters, certificates and qualifications mean.
Although the term ‘cosmetic surgery’ is widely used, there is no such specialty designation by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada in cosmetic surgery and it is performed by doctors with different qualifications. “Cosmetic surgeon,” “cosmetic plastic surgeon” and “facial plastic surgeon” are general terms that are used by many physicians, including physicians who may not have had any formal training in surgery.
In addition to talking to your doctor about his or her qualifications, you can also check to confirm that your doctor is licensed and what his or her qualifications are using the College’s website:
|
Family doctors
Some family doctors provide services either in addition to general family medicine or exclusively in a particular area, including cosmetic surgery or non-surgical cosmetic procedures. Family doctors are doctors who have undertaken medical training and take a further period of training (residency) of at least two years. Some may call themselves cosmetic surgeons even though they have no formal surgical training. Make sure you understand what their exact special training is for the surgery or procedure you are considering.
Specialist qualifications
A specialist is a doctor who has taken extensive additional training for a number of years in a particular field of medicine. Specialists are certified by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. Doctors who are certified in a surgical field are entitled to refer to themselves as a FRCSC (Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons of Canada). There is only one specialty in Canada that provides formal training and certification in cosmetic surgery for the face and body and that is the specialty of plastic surgery. Otolaryngologists (ear nose and throat surgeons) receive formal training in cosmetic surgery of the head and neck.
It is critical that you check your doctor’s qualifications and are confident that he or she has the appropriate skills and training to do the surgery you are considering. Whether or not you are seeing a specialist, your doctor should be prepared to answer any questions you have about his or her qualifications.
Where is cosmetic surgery performed?
In addition to finding out about the doctor performing the surgery, you need to know about the facility where the surgery will take place.
Cosmetic surgery is usually done in one of two types of facilities, either a hospital or a private clinic. A private clinic is one that is not affiliated with a hospital. While hospitals are required by law to meet certain standards and safety protocols, there are no laws like this that apply to private clinics.
Private clinics in Canada may belong to the Canadian Association for Accreditation of Ambulatory Surgical Facilities (CAAASF). The CAAASF requires private clinics to meet standards set for hospitals with regard to safety, personnel and sterilization.
Wherever you are having a procedure performed, appropriate safeguards should be in place to ensure your safety. If you are having surgery outside of a hospital, the clinic should have:
- Excellent infection control protocols;
- All necessary equipment;
- Clear procedures and plans to handle emergencies; and
- Well qualified staff.
It’s critical to ask questions about what happens if there are sudden, unexpected problems and how quickly help is available.
Other things to consider….
The decision to have any operation is significant. Think about it carefully, gather all the information you can and ensure that your expectations are realistic. Here are some things you can do before you make a decision:
-
Talk to your family doctor. This is a good place to start before making any decisions about cosmetic surgery. With your family physician you can discuss your reasons for wanting cosmetic surgery; your specific health issues which may be important when considering surgery; and general information about cosmetic procedures. For example, pregnancy, some medical conditions, and certain medications make cosmetic surgery unadvisable. Any medical conditions should also be discussed with your cosmetic surgery provider. Your family physician may also be familiar with the experience and training of surgeons who provide cosmetic procedures in your area.
-
Ask yourself why you want this procedure. Will it change your appearance the way you hoped? Are you doing it for yourself or to please someone else? Also consider if there alternatives to surgery that will give you the some of the benefits, including non-surgical cosmetic procedures with fewer risks. It’s important for you to consider these questions, in addition to talking to your doctor about whether your expectations are realistic.
-
Do your research. Hospitals and clinics offering the procedure you are considering can provide information that may help in your decision-making. Although many physicians have websites that provide details about their treatments, often with “before and after” photographs, websites are in themselves a form of advertising and photographs of patients before and after procedures may be best-case scenarios. Look for other objective information from multiple sources – friends, family, the internet, etc. When you see the physician, ask to see pictures of other patients that have had the procedures you are considering. If available, consider talking to past patients who have had the same procedure.
-
Contact the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. To learn about your doctor and his or her qualifications, you can call us at (416) 967-2600 ext. 626 or 1- 800-268-7096 ext.626 or visit the Doctor Search section of our website.
-
Book a consultation with the surgery provider. This is your opportunity to get the information you need to make a decision. You should not feel pressured to proceed just because you have had a consultation. This consultation should include a detailed medical history, a discussion about your aesthetic concerns, and a thorough explanation of all the options available to you to address your concerns. In addition, you should get a clear explanation of all the associated risks, benefits and complications associated with each option. It is very common for pre-operative pictures to be taken at the time of the initial consultation and the costs associated with each option are usually discussed at the time of the initial visit.
Take a list of questions with you. Be honest about your expectations. Ask about the doctor’s qualifications including how many procedures like this he or she has done, what kind of training or certification he or she has, complication rates and how complications are handled. A list of questions you can print and take with you is available at the end of this fact sheet.
-
Consider getting a second opinion. Different doctors have different approaches. Find one that suits you best.
When you are asked to sign an agreement consenting to the procedure, make sure you understand it and are confident with what you’re signing. Beware of any agreement that encourages you to make a quick decision. The decision to undergo cosmetic surgery is a significant one; take time to understand all the information given to you at the time of the consultation. Carefully read all of the information contained in the informed consent document.
Under no circumstances should you feel pressured to move ahead quickly into surgery. Take as much time as you need to make up your mind—and avoid any provider who makes you feel rushed.
If you have concerns
If the results of your cosmetic surgery are not what you expected, or you have other concerns, contact your treating cosmetic doctor. Together, you may be able to work out a solution.
If you do not feel that your concerns have been addressed adequately, and you have a concern about your doctor, please contact the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario:
-
Telephone:
(416) 967-2600 or 1-800-268-7096 ext. 306 -
Mail:
CPSO
80 College Street,
Toronto, Ontario
M5G 2E2
Cosmetic Surgery checklist
These questions will help you ask your doctor what you need to know before proceeding with Cosmetic Surgery. Print this Cosmetic Surgery checklist and take it with you to your appointment.
Non-Surgical Cosmetic Procedures checklist
These questions will help you ask your doctor what you need to know before proceeding with Non-Surgical Cosmetic procedures. Print this Non-Surgical Cosmetic Procedures checklist and take it with you to your appointment.
Rules tightened for cosmetic surgery in Ontario
The body governing Ontario's medical profession has approved several recommendations to tighten the regulations governing high-risk cosmetic surgery and procedures.
Assessing doctors (especially those not qualified in performing cosmetic surgery) and providing the public with more information on the risks were among the recommendations passed by the Council of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario on Monday.
The body said the move addresses concerns about the growing number of physicians in Ontario performing high-risk cosmetic procedures, especially those who are not licensed as plastic surgeons.
The recommendations come less than two months after a 37-year-old Toronto mother and real estate agent died after undergoing liposuction at a clinic.
While plastic surgeons are required to adhere to strict regulations and undergo licensing, little can be done to stop family doctors or general practitioners from calling themselves "cosmetic surgeons" and performing similar procedures under far less stringent guidelines.
Plastic surgeons require five years of specialized training to become licensed in the province, but any type of doctor can perform surgery.
At Monday's meeting, the college said it surveyed 548 doctors across the province who perform plastic surgery but are not considered to be plastic surgeons.
Officials said 16 of those doctors will be investigated further, however, their names were not made public.
"The college has the powers to investigate and then to proceed on with additional procedures that are required, which might extend to the point of suspension of practice and discipline," college president Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull told reporters.
"We're not going to release those names until we can do due diligence and insure that those people are properly trained, but I can reassure you we that will be assessing them very, very promptly."
Twenty other physicians were served with a notice of suspension because they didn't respond to the mandatory survey. Those doctors have 60 days to respond or their licence will be suspended.
With a report from CTV's Galit Solomon
Province investigates physicians
Globe and Mail
PATRICK WHITENovember 20, 2007
Ontario's medical watchdog is investigating 16 physicians who perform cosmetic surgery after the death of a 32-year-old Toronto liposuction patient two months ago prompted the group to accelerate a crackdown on the field.
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario sent out questionnaires last month to physicians in the province who conduct cosmetic procedures, asking what operations they perform and what their qualifications are.
Sixteen physicians, who have not been named, fall into what the college calls high- or moderate-risk categories. A high-risk doctor would be someone who is not a surgeon and is performing surgical procedures in an unaccredited facility, while moderate-risk physicians would include those with some surgical training who are performing procedures on parts of the body for which they have not been trained, said Dan Faulkner, director of research and quality management with the college.
"There is a concern for public safety," Mr. Faulkner said.
As part of the broader overhaul, the college voted to ban physicians from advertising as surgeons unless they have been trained as such.
Many family physicians in Ontario advertise as cosmetic surgeons even though they haven't completed the five years of study it takes to become a plastic surgeon. That is alleged to have been the case with Behnaz Yazdanfar, who performed liposuction on Toronto real-estate agent Krista Stryland before she died in September.
The college also voted to inspect all cosmetic surgery clinics and to require all physicians to report their qualifications. Doctors also would have to specify which of the more than 70 recognized cosmetic procedures they perform.
Currently, all assessments of non-hospital clinics are conducted on a voluntary basis by an independent third party, and the scope of practice a physician reports to the college may differ sharply from what he or she advertises on the web and in newspaper classifieds.
Until the college investigations are completed - a process that could take several months, according to college president Jeffrey Turnbull - the 16 doctors being scrutinized will continue to practise.
"If in such time we determine that those individuals are not appropriately trained or are putting individuals at risk, we will act immediately," Dr. Turnbull said.
The college also sent suspension notices to 20 doctors because they failed to return the questionnaire. Those doctors have 60 days to respond before their licences are suspended.
Growing public concern over the dangers of cosmetic surgery as well as pressure from doctors sparked the overhaul of Ontario's cosmetic surgery regulations. Among the biggest complaints were murky doctor qualifications, vague public warnings about the risks of surgery, shoddy oversight of cosmetic clinics and inadequate physician training, according to Mr. Faulkner.
Recent regulatory overhauls in western provinces also helped trigger the changes. In British Columbia, for example, family physicians are barred from practising cosmetic surgery and all cosmetic clinics must undergo regular inspections.
Dr. Turnbull suggested the B.C. changes were too drastic.
"I'm aware of many circumstances where individuals who are not surgeons in fact have had training that exceeds that of a plastic surgeon in this discipline," he said. "So I don't think it would be fair to characterize all family practitioners as unable to practice high-risk cosmetic procedures. It's all about the training."
Until investigations into the 16 physicians are completed, Dr. Turnbull advised patients to call the college or consult its website for advice on the qualifications a physician should have to conduct cosmetic procedures.
In all, the college expects to receive questionnaires from 568 doctors, 150 more names than the college had originally cobbled together from a combination of Internet sites, advertisements and internal records.
The college has been conducting a review of cosmetic surgery in the province since April, but its special Cosmetic Procedures Project only became a high priority after the death of Ms. Stryland.
Dr. Turnbull denied that the college has taken too long to clamp down on cosmetic surgery in the wake of Ms. Stryland's death and that of Toni Sullivan, 44, of Toronto after liposuction in 1989.
"I don't think we've dropped the ball," Dr. Turnbull said. "We've responded dramatically to the changes that are taking place around us and we're very pleased with this. We're working very quickly."
Ontario docs propose tougher cosmetic surgery rules
Toronto SUN - November 20, 2007
By Ian Robertson, SUN MEDIA
Ontario’s medical watchdog agency has put 36 doctors under a scope as it toughens policies for physicians and surgeons doing high-risk cosmetic procedures.
And after six months of reviews of bylaws, regulations and public concerns, the council of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario approved several guidelines on Monday.
Recommendations to be considered by the council in February, after they are circulated to all doctors and health organizations, include requiring doctors to use titles that do not imply specialization they lack — such as “cosmetic surgeon” — and expand the college’s authority to inspect non-hospital clinics.
“There is a concern for public safety,” Dan Faulkner, the college’s quality management director told councillors.
Plastic surgeons undergo five years of specialty training and are licensed by the province. The issue before the college is the growing number of family doctors and general practitioners who perform some of the procedures without being fully trained.
After several highly-publicized deaths — particularly from liposuction, a procedure local realtor Krista Stryland underwent the day she died Sept. 20 – plus western provinces setting new guidelines and limiting practices, Faulkner said some Ontario regulations have been tightened.
But he said “there is inconsistent oversight” and no provincial regulations for facilities where cosmetic procedures are conducted.
Of the 36 doctors being scrutinized, Faulkner said 16 will be checked for possibly operating without qualifications while doing “high-risk” procedures.
The other 20 were warned their license is forfeit unless they answer questions about their qualifications, practices, procedures and patient care within 60 days.
The 539 doctors who the college identified as doing cosmetic surgeries were given until Nov. 5 to return the detailed survey.
College president Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull said no doctors names will be released, since none was proven to have breached misconduct rules.
But Turnbull told reporters: “The college has the powers to investigate and then to proceed on with additional procedures that are required, which might extend to the point of suspension of practice and discipline.”
Vowing a speedy investigation of the 16 doctors and their clinics will safeguard the public, he promised any doctor found lacking can have their right to practice medicine banned “immediately.”
Turnbull would not discuss Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar, who did Stryland’s stomach liposuction at The Toronto Cosmetic Clinic.
The final report has not been submitted to Toronto coroner, Dr. James Edwards.
Turnbull denied the college has dragged its feet on toughening regulations.
Patients are invited to question the college about procedures and risks, but will not discuss an individual physician, he said, adding a detailed fact sheet was posted on its website Friday to help the public make informed choices.
Common facial cosmetic surgery were identified as procedures that include a “facelift, brow lift, eyelid surgery, ear surgery, and rhinoplasty (nose) surgery. Less invasive cosmetic facial surgeries include facial liposuction, facial implants, micro fat grafting, and some laser resurfacing procedures.”
Cosmetic surgery crackdown begins
Robert Cribb
Staff Reporters
Ontario's self-regulating medical watchdog is cracking down on family doctors who conduct cosmetic surgical procedures, demanding they prove their skills and come clean with patients about their credentials.
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario is investigating 16 doctors performing high-risk cosmetic procedures in private clinics that could be a danger to the public because of concerns about their qualifications and training.
A second group of 20 doctors have been put on notice that, if they do not answer mandatory questions about their qualifications, their licences will be suspended in 60 days.
For the first time in Ontario, the college is taking action against family doctors who call themselves "cosmetic surgeons" without having proper qualifications.
Under proposed new rules announced yesterday, the title "surgeon" will be reserved for physicians certified as surgical specialists by recognized medical bodies. Specialties such as plastic surgery take years of post-graduate medical training.
Currently, hundreds of family physicians in Ontario advertise themselves as cosmetic surgeons without any specialty designation or training.
"The regulation is to ensure people are appropriately using their title," said college spokesperson Kathryn Clarke. The change will be discussed by council again in February and, if passed, sent to the Ontario government for approval.
The death of 32-year-old Toronto real estate agent Krista Stryland prompted the college to move swiftly after years of poor policing in this area. On Sept. 20, Stryland died after Dr. Behnaz Yazdanfar performed liposuction at her Toronto Cosmetic Clinic to remove "pregnancy fat." Yazdanfar declined repeated requests for an interview.
The Ontario coroner's office is still investigating the Stryland case. No decision has been made on whether there will be an inquiry into her death. Yazdanfar continues to practise in her Toronto clinic.
Yazdanfar's website pitches her as a "premier Toronto cosmetic surgeon" with an "impressive résumé" featuring "extensive" experience, medical credentials and professional affiliations. She is not a certified surgeon.
In September, a Star investigation documented years of dithering by the medical watchdog about whether to crack down on unqualified cosmetic surgeons.
College council briefing notes and discussion papers dating back to the early 1990s, obtained by the Star, revealed years of lax standards and unenforced regulations even as college officials were quietly raising concerns about family physicians conducting cosmetic procedures without oversight or training.
Three weeks after the Star story was published, the college sent mandatory surveys to 406 physicians requesting details about their cosmetic procedures practices to determine whether they should receive "a practice assessment" by the college.
College officials yesterday refused to name the 16 doctors who are the subject of "immediate" action.
"The 16 we know to be practising in a high-risk circumstance where they are doing relatively invasive procedures out of a hospital setting by individuals who may not be adequately trained," said Dr. Jeffrey Turnbull, the college president.
The 16 will be evaluated by trained physician assessors as soon as possible, officials say. But those doctors have the right to continue practising until that time.
"We won't release the names until we can do due diligence and ensure these people are appropriately trained. But I can reassure you we will be reassessing them properly," said Turnbull.
If patients have questions about their doctor, they should look at the college website at cpso.on.ca, said Turnbull. The college recently posted tips for the public on what questions they should ask about a physician's qualifications before they undergo a cosmetic procedure.
Beyond the doctors, when the procedures are performed outside of a hospital at "independent health facilities," the college wants to inspect the premises and equipment used.
Every physician who performs cosmetic procedures at one of these facilities must inform the college in writing of what services they intend on providing and they must submit to an inspection that could include direct observation of the performance of procedures. The inspection will take place at least once every four years.
The council is making "significant steps forward" to protect the public, Turnbull said.
"We are going to start moving quickly. You'll see in the next several months we'll be out assessing many of the different practices where there are cosmetic procedures taking place in what we consider higher risk circumstances," he said.
Turnbull said the college was not bowing to pressure from the government to better police its members. He said the college was responding to the public and other doctors who are concerned.
Toronto lawyer Alan Rachlin applauded the college's changes but also said there is nothing in place to protect the public today.
"It doesn't address what do you do in the meantime? There is no protection in place for the public right now," Rachlin said. The patient questionnaire on the college website doesn't cut it for Rachlin.
"How the hell will they get that in the hands of a consumer and ensure the consumers look at it?" he asked.
"Again, if you walk into a clinic office and see 30 diplomas on the wall, are you qualified to know if those diplomas mean anything or not?"
In 1989, Toni Sullivan, a 44-year-old Unionville mother and real estate agent, died after cosmetic surgery. Her death prompted a 1990 inquest that recommended the college establish standards for quality of care at private clinics and the credentials of the doctors performing surgery there. But mandatory oversight of cosmetic doctors and their facilities hasn't been pursued in Ontario until now.
In Alberta and B.C., all surgeons and their surgical facilities must be licensed for each procedure they perform. They cannot advertise themselves as cosmetic surgeons without holding a surgical specialty. Doctors who call themselves cosmetic surgeons are not required to meet any of the strict training and oversight rules that govern plastic surgeons. In addition to five years of specialized surgical training, plastic surgeons must pass a national exam and be certified as members of the Royal College.
"I was a general practitioner before I became a specialist," says Dr. Brian Peterson, a plastic surgeon in Kelowna, B.C., and president of the Canadian Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, which represents plastic surgeons.
"As a GP, you have medical school and an internship. You have no experience doing surgery and no appreciation for all those things that can go wrong. Five years of surgical training teaches you how to select patients properly and what to do when things go wrong."
Peterson recently wrote all of the provincial college registrars urging more rigour when it comes to monitoring medical advertising claims.
"Advertising should not be misleading," he wrote. "Any physician stating they are a surgeon, should hold a specialist certification in surgery from the Royal College (of Physicians and Surgeons) and hold similar privileges at their regional hospital to provide comprehensive care of patients. Anything less than this is misleading to patients and allows the potential for harm."
Karyn Wagner, executive director of the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons, said the public "should be made aware that there is a difference between a certified plastic surgeon and a general practitioner conducting cosmetic surgery."
The victims
Krista Stryland, 32, was a successful Toronto real estate agent and mom to a 3-year-old son. Her father, Don Tabacoff, remembered her as always smartly dressed, with flowing hair and a cheerful smile. She didn't tell anyone about her liposuction surgery. She died on Sept. 20.
Toni Sullivan, 44,, also a realtor and mother, died from a blood clot two days after liposuction surgery on June, 30, 1989. An inquest was held and the coroner's jury found her medical care suffered and her death could have been prevented.
The practitioners
The college's crackdown is aimed at family doctors who perform invasive cosmetic surgeries such as face lifts, liposuction and tummy tucks.
Regulators say these procedures should be performed by licensed plastic surgeons, who are medical doctors with five years of specialized training in surgical procedures and have hospital operating privileges.
They pass national exams and are certified as specialists in plastic surgery by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada.
Plastic surgeon fellows hold the designation FRCSC (Fellow Royal College Surgeons Canada), which mandates ongoing professional development. There are 441 active plastic surgeon fellows in Canada.
They also perform highly complex procedures such as face reconstruction for accident victims and skin grafts for burn victims. OHIP will pay for medically necessary plastic surgery but not procedures deemed strictly cosmetic.
The numbers
150% increase, between 2002 and 2006, in number of physicians who reported doing cosmetic surgery
6th Toronto's ranking in North America for number of cosmetic surgeries performed
17 number of years since an inquest into the liposuction death of Toni Sullivan recommended quality of care standards at private clinics and proper credentials for doctors performing surgery there
85.5% of all cosmetic procedures are sought by women
$2,500 lowest price charged for liposuction at the Toronto Cosmetic Clinic
$6,000 lowest price charged for breast augmentation at the Toronto Cosmetic Clinic
$210M amount spent on cosmetic surgical procedures in Ontario in 2003
Monday, October 22, 2007
CPSO Council issues statement on cosmetic procedures
These included:
1. To assess physicians performing high-risk cosmetic surgical procedures where there is no evidence of adequate training.
2. To review the College’s Change in Scope of Practice policy to determine the best way to ensure compliance.
3. To evaluate and propose different approaches that could be used to oversee out-of-hospital facilities/clinics.
4. To develop a public information initiative to inform the public about cosmetic procedures, including their risks.
The CPSO has now identified members who perform cosmetic procedures through a variety of sources and they will be receiving a letter with a detailed questionnaire to complete about the cosmetic procedures they are providing to patients. This will help them understand where they practice, the services provided in their facility or facilities and the formal training and continuing professional development that has been completed. An explanatory letter and the questionnaire were sent to these physicians by mail on October 17, 2007. The Questionnaire must be returned by November 5, 2007.
A copy of the letter and the questionnaire are at: http://www.cpso.on.ca/Info_physicians/CL_Questionnaire.pdf
and
http://www.cpso.on.ca/Info_physicians/Questionnaire_cosmetic.pdf
Completion is mandatory for physicians performing cosmetic procedures.
The College is committed to having complete information about all physicians working in this field and ensuring that members are practicing only in areas where they have the knowledge, skills and training generally but in particular for medical procedures that involve significant risk.
The CPSO intends to assess all physicians who are performing high-risk cosmetic procedures where there may not have been adequate training. In addition, Council has approved the development of an implementation plan to require members to comply with the policy to report a change in scope of practice or re-entry to practice.
Dr. Jeff Turnbull, MD, FRCPC, the president of the CPSO said that this action is an extremely high priority for the College and he would appreciate the cooperation of the members of the College. He said that he would keep members informed of any new initiatives particularly after our Council meeting in November when additional measures will be considered to ensure adequate oversight of high risk procedures in out-of-hospital facilities.